Planning & quotations

How to Compare Roofing Quotes: What Should Be Included?

Two roofing quotations can have very different totals because they describe different jobs. Before deciding which is better value, put the scopes side by side. A useful comparison is about what will be done and how uncertainty is handled, not just the final number.

By Roofcare LondonUpdated 3 min read

Roofer laying slate tiles onto battens during roof installation
Illustrative roofing image from the Roofcare London website.

The key point

Compare the diagnosed defect, area of work, materials, access, disposal, VAT, payment terms and guarantees. Ask how hidden defects are handled. If those details differ or are missing, the lowest total is not yet evidence of the best-value solution.

Start with the problem and the proposed outcome

Ask each contractor to state what has been found and which work is intended to resolve it. A description such as repair roof does not establish whether the same tiles, flashing or roof section are included in each price.

Record exclusions explicitly. If a garage roof, gutter run or chimney is outside the quotation, it should not be left to assumption. A clear boundary helps both parties understand what the completed job should achieve.

A quotation comparison sheet

ItemQuestion to settle
Defect and areaWhat is being repaired or replaced, and why?
MaterialsWhich covering, system and associated details are included?
AccessWhat arrangements are included, and for how long?
Preparation and wasteWhat is removed, retained, disposed of or made good?
ApprovalsWho checks and arranges any necessary approvals?
Total and paymentIs VAT included where applicable, and when is payment due?
Extra workHow are newly discovered defects priced and agreed?
GuaranteesWho provides them, what do they cover and what are the conditions?

Use the same headings for every quotation. A blank entry is a question to ask, not permission to assume the most favourable answer.

Ask for explanation, not just reassurance

Inspection photographs can help show the area being discussed. Ask the contractor to relate those photographs to the written recommendation. A close-up without location or explanation is less useful than a labelled record of the defect.

NFRC's homeowner guide recommends written quotations, clarification of uncertain points and comparison of like-for-like work rather than selecting only the cheapest price. [1]

You do not need to become a roofing specialist to ask what is included. A contractor should be able to explain the scope without relying on phrases such as all necessary work to cover unresolved details.

Agree the process for concealed problems

Some condition may remain unknown until a covering is opened. Ask how that uncertainty is reflected in the quotation, how evidence will be provided and how an additional price will be agreed before extra work proceeds.

This is different from agreeing an undefined contingency that can be spent without discussion. Record the approval contact and any agreed limit. Where more extensive work changes the original assumptions, the specification and any approval requirements may need revisiting.

Compare actual guarantee documents

A material warranty and a workmanship guarantee can have different providers and conditions. Ask for the document that will apply to the proposed job, not a general statement about how long a product can last.

Check any requirements for maintenance, registration or an approved installer. Do not assume a guarantee is insurance-backed or transferable unless the applicable terms say so. Also keep the contractor's details and the agreed scope with the completion records.

Choose after the gaps are resolved

A clearer quotation may cost more because it includes work that another has excluded. Alternatively, a higher proposal may cover unnecessary work. Ask for the difference to be explained rather than assuming either price is right.

Roofcare London can discuss the scope of your roofing enquiry and provide a quotation for the agreed work. Use the form below with the postcode and a description, or call about an active leak. For indicative external cost context, see roofing costs in London.

Sources & further reading

Guidance links supplied with the articles; important rules should be reconfirmed for your property. These sources support the linked factual points; they do not endorse Roofcare London or replace an assessment of your property.

  1. NFRC: Homeowner's guide to roof work (PDF)

Discuss the work your property needs

Explore the relevant roofing service, or describe the address and problem in the enquiry form below.

Request a roofing quotation

Related advice

Keep planning your roofing work

View all roofing guides →